Holy mackerel. I opened my paper this morning to see my scowling face staring back at me. (Click on image to get a clearer view.)
Yes, this promotional ad for the Indy Star appeared on page A11. It was a bit strange to be sitting at my breakfast table, drinking coffee, turning the pages, and then see my tough-guy look, along with a photo of Tim Evans, who looked a lot nicer.
But after I finished with my double-take, I read the ad closely. It was about our investigative coverage of the Indiana State Fair tragedy last summer.
I have to say, that was a huge story. And we covered the hell out of it.
The accident was horrific. On a blustery night at the main grandstands, the massive stage rigging collapsed in high winds and fell forward onto the crowd. Seven people died. Dozens more were badly hurt.
I was part of the investigative team at The Star, under the direction of Alvie Lindsay, that tried to figured out what happened and why.
But even before we did that, our breaking news team was all over the story. The collapse happened late in the evening, right on our deadline. We had little time to get fancy: just get the facts and images. Fortunately, we had a reporter and photographer on the scene, covering the concert. They saw the rigging topple over, and captured it for the next day’s paper.
Bobby King, one of our best writers, was called into the office to write the story from the phoned-in reports. He was working on tight deadline but crafted a wonderful story.
The next day, Sunday, investigative reporter Tim Evans came in and began digging into the story. His story for Monday appeared under the headline: Could collapse have been prevented? It began:
It’s a troubling question in the midst of tragedy but one that state officials must now try to answer: Was there something that could have been done to avoid the deadly catastrophe that took place Saturday at the Indiana State Fair?
On Sunday, various state agencies began the sobering task of trying to explain just how five people were killed and 45 others were injured when an overhead stage rigging came crashing down on people waiting for the start of a Sugarland concert.
Other reporters also began writing mini profiles of the victims, covering the post-accident press conferences and interviewing witnesses.
Here is what our Monday package looked like:





On Monday, Heather and I were pulled into the story. We teamed up with Tim and made it our mission to dig deep.
Our job was to find out everything we could about the stage rigging: what kind of material was used, who designed it, who erected it, who inspected it and anything interesting we could find out about any of those people.
After spending a few hours bothering every state official we could find, and interviewing all kinds of experts, we came up with a surprising finding. The rigging had never been inspected, due to an odd state law that exempts rigging and scaffolding from building inspections.
Our story began:
If you’re wondering which Indiana agency regulates the massive stage rigging at the State Fairgrounds, the answer is apparently none of them.
If you’re wondering how often the structures are inspected by the government, the answer is apparently never.
The Indiana Department of Homeland Security, which inspects buildings, elevators and amusement park rides, does not regulate outdoor stages and did not inspect the stage at the Indiana State Fair before heavy winds toppled the heavy structure onto a crowd Saturday night.
Here’s part of the package, which began on the bottom of page A1:
On Tuesday, we pushed forward in another direction. We wanted to know what exactly happened on the night of the disaster, and why.
For days, state officials had been blaming the accident and high winds on “a freak act of God.”
We decided to do a tick-tock story. When was the weather alert sounded? When did officials begin evacuating people? When did the stage rigging collapse?
We found the officials had delayed for precious minutes:
Emergency responders nationwide know what a National Weather Service warning means: Take cover. Immediately.
But that wasn’t the message Indiana State Fair officials delivered to concertgoers when they received that warning — the most serious alarm the National Weather Service can sound — at 8:39 p.m. Saturday. Instead, fair officials waited six minutes and then told 12,000 Sugarland fans a very different message: The show would go on.
Here’s how the package looked:
While our investigative coverage was running, other reporters from around the newsroom — metro, features and sports — were chasing their own angles for daily and the weekend. The Star, I am proud to say, “flooded the zone” and gave readers days and weeks of meaty information.
Here is one of my favorite human-interest stories from the week, written by summer intern Alex Campbell:
For our investigation team, we needed to push the story the story forward again. Tim, Heather and I spent a few days look around the country to see whether other state fairs had better safety procedures, and how many had temporary outdoor stages like Indiana had.
We discovered the numerous other states had tougher regulations on outdoor stages. Several state fairs had permanent outdoor stages to avoid the possibility of a disaster.
This is how our story began:
The Beatles played on an open-air, temporary stage at the Indiana State Fair in 1964.
So did Diana Ross and the Supremes (1968), New Kids on the Block (1989), Garth Brooks (1992) and hundreds of other acts over the years.
But now, some officials are beginning to wonder whether the decades-old era of a temporary stage at the State Fair should end.
In the wake of the Aug. 13 disaster at the fairgrounds, where high winds toppled the stage rigging, crushing fans waiting to hear the country duo Sugarland, some say it might be time to consider following the lead of Iowa, Illinois and other states that have permanent outdoor stages.
And here is how the package looked:
Our investigation continued stories over many weeks, and involved open-record requests, digging through documents, doing interviews and much general reporting.
All in all, we found that emergency plans were inadequate, communications were slipshod, the construction was below standard and oversight by the state fair commission was a joke.
When two official teams of investigators, hired by the state, gave their report months later, that’s exactly what they found too. Here’s the Star’s coverage of that:

Last month, we were recognized for our coverage with a first-place statewide award for investigative reporting by the Society of Professional Journalists.
We won other awards for fair coverage too, including first place for breaking news and first place for feature reporting.
And today, we had a nice house ad, right in our own paper. (Remember that scowling photo of me at the top?)
I’m just sorry to say that Heather Gillers wasn’t mentioned in that ad. A few months ago, she left The Star to take a job as an investigative reporter with the Chicago Tribune. I guess we don’t mention people who don’t work here any more in our ads.
So Heather, here you go. This award has your name on it too.















Posted by John on Deadline 














